01 Roofing
How to read a roofing quote
Four contractors, four very different numbers, and no obvious way to compare them. The difference is almost never the shingle.
Shingles are the cheapest part of a roof and the only part most people shop on. The parts that decide whether someone is back up there in eight years are the ones you cannot see from the driveway, and only some of them will appear on any given quote.
The four lines to look for
- Step flashing at wall intersections, and every penetration re flashed rather than re caulked.
- Ice and water membrane in the valleys and at the eaves, which matters in a Maryland freeze thaw winter.
- A deck that is walked and inspected rather than shingled straight over, with replacement decking agreed in advance.
- Balanced intake and exhaust ventilation. Without it the attic cooks the shingles from below and can void the manufacturer’s warranty.
If a bid leaves things out, ask which of those four items are in it. Usually that is the whole difference between two numbers.
What a quote you can compare looks like
Materials, labor, tear off and disposal, a decking allowance and contingency shown as separate lines. Unit rates stated, so a surprise on the day is priced against something you already agreed. And two warranties stated separately: the manufacturer’s on the materials, and the contractor’s on the workmanship.
A quote written that way can be priced against line for line by anyone else. One that cannot be compared usually has a reason not to be.
Request a written estimate
02 Roofing
Repair or replace? The honest test
Age, pattern and location. A single leak at a penetration is a repair. Granule loss across a whole elevation is not.
Age is the first filter. An asphalt roof past about twenty two years is usually spending money badly on repairs. After that it is about the pattern of what you see.
- A discrete leak at one penetration, missing shingles after a wind event or damaged flashing: often a repair.
- Granule loss across the whole south face, curling edges, or leaks in several different planes: the field itself is finished.
Not every roof needs replacing, and a good contractor will say so. What none should do is sell you a repair on a roof that is genuinely finished, or a replacement on a roof that has ten good years in it.
What to ask for
An honest read in writing, with photographs of what was found. For storm damage, dated photographs and an itemized scope your adjuster can work from.
Roofing, in detail
03 Permits
What an unpermitted deck costs you at resale
The saving is real and immediate. The cost arrives years later, in front of a buyer’s inspector.
Both Frederick and Montgomery County require a permit for decks above a modest height, and for anything carrying a roof. It also frequently triggers setback review and, in some neighborhoods, HOA review.
A permitted deck goes through a design that can actually be approved, footings dug to the required depth and inspected before pouring, and a final inspection signed off. You get the paperwork, which the next buyer’s inspector will ask for.
The same is true inside the house. A like for like cosmetic kitchen refit generally does not need a permit. Anything structural, or that moves electrical circuits or plumbing, generally does, and unpermitted structural work becomes your problem at resale.
The one inspection people skip
Footings. It is the one inspection people are most tempted to skip, and the one holding the whole deck up.
How we permit a deck
04 Bathrooms
Why a five year old shower already smells
Almost always the same answer: no waterproofing membrane, or no pre slope beneath it.
Tile is not waterproof. Grout is not waterproof. Water passes through a tiled surface, and what stops it reaching your joists is the waterproofing membrane behind and beneath the tile. That is the layer cheap bathrooms skip.
A shower installed over plain cement board with no membrane looks identical to a properly built one for about five years. Then the smell starts, the tile at the base sounds hollow, and the repair is not a bathroom: it is a bathroom plus the subfloor, and occasionally the ceiling of the room below.
What a shower should have behind the tile
- A bonded membrane across walls, floor and curb, lapped, sealed and tested before a tile goes on.
- A pre slope to the drain beneath the membrane, not just above it, so water never sits in the mortar bed.
- Every valve, spout and fixing through the membrane sealed with the manufacturer’s own collar.
- Extraction ducted to the outside, sized for the room, on a timer or humidistat. Most mold problems are ventilation problems.
How we build a bathroom
05 Kitchens
Where the work in a kitchen actually goes
Two kitchens with identical cabinets can be very different projects. The difference is behind the finish.
The hard part of a kitchen is rarely the part you can see. The difference between two similar looking kitchens is almost always structural, electrical or plumbing work hidden behind the finish.
- Removing a wall that turns out to be load bearing means a beam, and a beam means engineering, posts and a load path down to the footing.
- Moving a sink across the room means new drainage with the correct fall.
- Adding an island with power means a circuit run under the floor.
None of it shows in the finished photograph, and all of it is real work. The two variables that decide the scope are whether the layout moves, and the cabinetry tier.
Is that wall load bearing?
Joist direction, what is above it and the foundation below usually tell you, but usually is not good enough. Where there is doubt, open a small inspection hole; where it is bearing, a structural engineer sizes the beam.
Kitchen remodeling
06 Decks
The ledger board: why decks fall down
Two failure modes account for most deck collapses, and both are visible from underneath if you know where to look.
When a deck collapses, it is rarely the posts or the joists. It is the connection where the deck meets the house: the ledger board.
- Attachment: nails instead of structural lag screws or through bolts, which pull out under live load.
- Water: no flashing above the ledger, so rain runs behind it, the rim joist rots quietly for a decade, and the fixings eventually have nothing left to hold.
Check yours this weekend
- Look for flashing above the ledger where it meets the house.
- Look for bolts or structural screws through the ledger, not just nails.
- Look for proper joist hangers and post bases.
- Press the rim joist behind the ledger. Soft wood means it is time for a professional to look.
If the frame is sound, re decking and re railing can be excellent value. If the ledger was never flashed and the rim joist is soft, patching it is not something we will do.
Deck construction
07 Hiring
Eight questions to ask any contractor
Including the one almost nobody asks. The answers tell you more than any portfolio.
- Will you put the scope in writing before I commit? If not, what was quoted is an opening position.
- Who manages the job day to day, and are the trades employed or subcontracted?
- Tell me about a job that went wrong, and what you did about it.
- What is your Maryland home improvement license number, and can I see your certificate of insurance?
- How are change orders handled: priced and signed before the work, or after?
- Who is my one point of contact from walk through to punch list?
- Which warranties apply, and are they written into the estimate?
- Who pulls the permit, and who meets the inspector?
Ask us the same eight. You should get a straight answer to every one, at the first meeting.
How we work